In The Catcher in the Rye, what does Holden mean by "Don't ever tell anybody anything. If you do, you start missing everybody"?

When Holden says "Don't ever tell anybody anything. If you do, you start missing everybody," he means that getting close with others and building meaningful bonds will eventually end in heartbreak and loneliness. Holden's traumatic past has conditioned him to remain aloof and distant from others as a psychologically protective measure. His fear of losing another important person influences him to remain introverted and repress his difficult emotions.

J. D. Salinger’s novel The Catcher in the Rye ends with the teen antihero, Holden Caulfield, likely in some kind of mental health facility. He’s just let the reader know that everything that he’s told the reader about, he’s written in this place. The quote listed in the question encompasses the last two sentences in his story. The final thought from Holden has several meanings. One of its meanings is literal. Holden is admitting that he misses the people that he’s been talking about. Despite the fact that he’s spent much of the story describing these people as phonies and morons, as it turns out, he feels a connection to the sources of his contempt. The sentence also carries a dramatic meaning. Holden is being sweeping and grand. He’s not saying that he misses specific people or certain individuals. He’s not being nuanced; he’s being expansive. The exaggerated meaning ties back to the polarizing quality of Holden’s diction. Throughout the story, Holden tends to speak in absolute terms, like early on in the novel, when he says, “People never believe you.” Additionally, the quote contains a sentimental meaning. Although Holden has presented himself as a misanthrope—someone who’d rather be a “deaf-mute bastard” than live among people—it appears as if Holden possesses something of a soft spot for human beings after all. Finally, one could argue that the meaning is deceptive. At the start of chapter 3, Holden warns the reader, “I’m the most terrific liar you ever saw in your life.” Without totally discounting Holden’s statement, it’s possible to argue that Holden is not the most reliable of narrators. Thus, this statement could be taken with a grain of salt.

This is the last line of the novel, and the context is Holden's conversation with his older brother, D. B.: D.B. asked me what I thought about all this stuff I just finished telling you about. I didn't know what the hell to say. If you want to know the truth, I don't know what I think about it. I'm sorry I told so many people about it. About all I know is, I sort of miss everybody I told about. Even old Stradlater and Ackley, for instance. I think I even miss that goddam Maurice. It's funny. Don't ever tell anybody anything. If you do, you start missing everybody. Holden is speaking to the power of memory and empathy. People come alive for him as he recalls them, and this makes him miss them. This shows us two conflicting things about Holden. First, he wants to hold people at a distance because his experience has been that when he gets close to someone, he experiences pain and loss. He wrongly feels that by isolating himself, he can save himself from pain. Further, not only are the memories painful, telling people about them builds an intimacy that he finds threatening because it can lead to more pain. But despite his advice to cut oneself off from memory and empathy, this passage shows just how humane and empathetic Holden is. He likes people, even the people he would have a good reason to hate. His feelings are alive, and he responds deeply to others. He longs for connection. This sensitivity to others shows that Holden is not oriented toward using people, but toward loving them—this trait helps redeem him as a character. Salinger also suggests that the very sensitivity that causes Holden to have a breakdown is also at the core what makes him human.

Holden makes this comment at the end of the book, and this quote highlights his fragile emotional state and inability to cope with difficult, complex feelings. Instead of cultivating meaningful relationships and sharing his thoughts with people he cares about, Holden psychologically puts up "walls" to protect himself. When examining this quote, it is important to analyze Holden's background and social experiences. Throughout the story, he is portrayed as a hypercritical, anxious teenager who is extremely immature and judgmental. Holden fears becoming an adult and struggles to cope with his traumatic childhood experiences. When Holden was thirteen, his younger brother, Allie, died of leukemia, which negatively affected his emotional state and social development. In addition to experiencing his brother's death, Holden also witnessed his classmate, James Castle, commit suicide. His parents are also aloof, and his older brother, D. B., moved away when he needed him the most. These traumatic experiences have a negative impact on Holden's psychology, emotional stability, and social life. He never fully copes with Allie's death and purposely distances himself from those he cares about as a protective measure. A prime example is Holden's refusal to call Jane Gallagher. Jane is one of the few people who genuinely cares about Holden, but he continually hesitates to call her. Instead, Holden interacts with remote, insensitive individuals who do not understand him. Holden believes that if he shares his feelings and opens up to people he cares about, they will eventually abandon him, leaving him traumatized and lonely. Unfortunately, Holden is too immature and emotionally scarred to understand that repressing difficult feelings and distancing himself will only make his situation worse. The audience recognizes that Holden would benefit from communicating with others, expressing his difficult feelings in a composed manner, and coping with the death of his younger brother.

When Holden makes this statement, he means that once you get close to someone and depend on them for emotional support and you have a real connection, you can really miss that person, because they can leave you. People leave, they die, they are unreliable. Holden technically has lost both his brothers. Allie, his younger brother died, and D.B. has left and gone to California. He feels very distant from D.B., because he thinks he is a sell-out, writing movie scripts instead of serious books. Two people Holden really needs in his life are gone.Jane Gallagher, the girl that Holden really cares about, she seems far away to him. He misses her too, even though all he has to do is call her. He can't or he won't, and because of this inability to get close to someone, other than his sister, he suffers from isolation.He fears sharing his feelings with anyone; he has developed a protection strategy, don't get close to anyone and you are safe. He is seriously misguided in this belief, and because of it, he has an emotional breakdown.

内CatcherRyeHolden的意思是: 永远别告诉任何人万一你开始思念每个人?

快速回答 :

Holden说:"永远别告诉任何人并搭建有意义的联结最终会以心碎和孤独告终。Holden的创伤性过去令他远离他人作为一种心理防护措施恐惧失去另一个重要人物会影响他保持内向并抑制他困难的情感

PDF系统

专家回答

|认证教育者

J.公元前赛林格小说CatcherRye端端对eHolden Caulfi可能在某种精神卫生院他只是让阅读者知道他告诉阅读者的一切, 他写在这个地方问题中的引文包含他故事中最后两句

Holden的最后思想有几个意义其意义之一是字面化Holden承认他怀念他所讲的人尽管他花了很多故事描述这些人假冒和白痴, 事实证明,他觉得连接出自他的蔑视

句子还含有戏剧意义Holden正在扫荡和盛大他不是说怀念特定人或某些个人他没有小题大做开阔度夸大意义回溯到Holden质量极化词典.在整个故事中 Holden往往用绝对语言说话,像小说中的早期,他说,“人们从不相信你”。

外加引用含有情感意义Holden自称为恶意私生子, 而不是活在人间, 似乎Holden拥有人类软点的东西归根结底。

归根结底,人们可以争辩说,它的意思有欺骗性。起始点第三章Holden警告阅读者,“我是你一生中见过最优秀的骗子。”不完全忽略Holden的语句,就可能说Holden不是最可靠的旁白者。因而,这个语句可带一粒盐

经enots编辑核准

|认证教育者

这是小说最后一行上下文是Holden和他哥哥DB.:

D.B.问我我对刚讲完的东西想了什么我不知道该说什么如果你想知道实情我不知道我怎么想很抱歉我告诉了这么多人关于我所知道的是, 我有点怀念每个人我讲过连老Stradlater和Ackley都行我想我甚至怀念那该死的莫里斯.真有趣永远别告诉任何人万一有,你开始缺失每个人

Holden向记忆和同情之力说话人为他活来像他回想他们,这使他怀念他们

显示Holden有两件冲突第一,他想保持距离因为他的经验是当他接近某人时经历痛苦和损失他错误地感到,通过孤立自己,他可以拯救自己免受痛苦不仅记忆令人痛心向人们讲故事建立亲密关系因为他发现威胁因为它可能导致更多痛苦

但尽管他建议切除记忆和同情心, 这部分显示Holden人性化和同情心有多强他爱人连他有很好理由憎恨的人心存感想深深响应他人他渴望连接对他人的这种敏感显示Holden不是面向使用人,而是面向爱人-这个特征帮助他恢复性格

赛林格还暗示敏感度导致霍尔登崩溃也是核心

经enots编辑核准

|认证教育者

Holden在书尾作此评论,本引用突出他脆弱的情感状态和无法处理困难复杂情感Holden非但没有培养有意义的关系并分享他所关心的人的想法,分析Holden背景与社会经历很重要在整个故事中,他被描述为超临界焦虑少年,极不成熟和判断力极强Holden恐惧成成年人并努力处理创伤童年经历

Holden十三岁时弟弟阿力白血病死亡不利地影响他的情感状态和社会发展Holden除经历兄弟死讯外,詹姆斯卡斯尔...........父母疏远哥哥D....... 最需要时移位

创伤经历对Holden的心理学、情感稳定与社会生活有负面影响他从不完全处理Allie的死亡问题并刻意与那些他所关心的人相距甚远作为一种保护性措施一个很好的例子就是Holden拒绝调用简加拉格.Jane是少数真正关心Holden的人之一,但他持续犹豫不决地打给她。Holden则与不理解他的远程不敏感个人交互

Holden相信,如果分享他的情感并开放给他所关心的人,他们最终会抛弃他,留下他精神创伤和孤独感可惜Holden太不成熟和情感上受创无法理解抑制难感和疏远自己只会使状况恶化观众确认Holden会从与他人通信、以组合方式表达难感并处理弟弟死亡问题中得益

经enots编辑核准